Most of the music is broadcast in some lossy format, where details are missed, and the overall quality is reduced. Most of the time, people who prefer the quality of records over digital generally love to have a physical copy of an album. Is that true? Please check it out…)) The funny thing about the vinyl debate is this: Some of the most vocal people weighing in on the vinyl side are … probably hard of hearing. Update: rob- thanks for your views. Sonically, vinyl has both strengths and weaknesses compared to digital files, just as movie buffs have argued over the pros and cons of 35mm film against 4K digital. Some listeners honestly feel that the defects vinyl introduces somehow make it more attractive or “warmer.” But from any objective standpoint, there’s no justification in calling the sound of vinyl records “better.” Submit a question to “Ask the Expert.” Vinyl records sound better than CDs because they don’t experience a conversion like a compact disc. If a song is recorded on tape, its conversion to vinyl better preserves the original sound … There’s a huge community of people buying, collecting, and reselling vinyl, because it always keeps its purchase value, and even increases in value. Sometimes. The music floats within the middle range of pitches, which is comfortable for humans to listen to. When you acquire a record, you’re not just buying some album. You talk to people, and ask their opinions and suggestions, and ultimately make friends. "There's basically nothing you can do to make an hour-long album on one record sound good," Gonsalves said. Bands who meet those criteria are the ones you can find in a record shop. Vinyl is far more high-quality. But there is a downside, any specks of dust or damage to the disc can be heard as noise or static. On a theoretical level, there's just no reason it should be the case that vinyl sounds better. Real Reason Why Vinyl Sounds Better Than A CD – Detailed Explanation 07/01/2017 02/18/2020 turntable01 0 Comments How it looks to us, and this became a general conclusion when we read various audiophile forums and blogs, it is not a matter of the vinyl record itself or of a CD. m_gallery_json = "https://blog.oregonlive.com/photogallery/4450/16373446.json"; m_gallery_type = "photo"; Gallery: Adam Gonsalves at Telegraph Mastering. Registration on or use of this site constitutes acceptance of our User Agreement, Privacy Policy and Cookie Statement, and Your California Privacy Rights (each updated 1/1/20). Vinyl distorts it. Nope. When I visited Gonsalves, he was working on My Brightest Diamond's new album — from his computer. Music sounds better played on a good turntable than it does from files or CDs. This one isn’t up for dispute. 30'000+ Radiostations perfectly categorized by countries & genres, "Hey! Vinyl can give a better sound, but usually, it doesn't. Vinyl, for the most part, avoided the ‘loudness war.' Why CDs May Actually Sound Better Than Vinyl Chris Kornelis January 27, 2015 James Russell's mother told him that his first invention was the “automated battleship” he built when he was 6. Vinyl sounds better than MP3s ever could. Some apps and websites make the process much more convenient. Sorry, friends. People who prefer vinyl tend to be quite picky about what they listen to. With the rise of digital music (CDs included), it's possible to make a track sound louder than it naturally should. Since vinyl is an analog format, it can suffer from the same problems. This article hopes to answer some questions concerning vinyl weight. Please check it out…)) The funny thing about the vinyl debate is this: Some of the most vocal people weighing in on the vinyl side are … probably hard of hearing. What vinyl can't do Otherwise, "that's a hard path for a needle to trace.". A few exceptions exist: Clear vinyl, picture discs and glow-in-the-dark pressings are more susceptible to poor playback. They sound different, and that's exactly the point. Analog is mechanical. But, the bottom line question is: does it really matter? But, vinyl? Very few additives can be mixed into clear vinyl without jeopardizing the opacity, which means there is a potential for worse sound quality, albeit this drop is often imperceptible to the common listener. And that’s lovely. Here's why: Digital audio is great at keeping a constant quality which is fairly high. A turntable’s basic function is to pick up the vibrations, emitted by the grooves of your records, via the tonearm and cartridge.The stylus then measures and converts these vibrations into an electrical signal that is amplified into sweet, sweet music, via your loudspeakers. The problem here is that it had a tremendous result on the audio quality. But it will sound more vinyl-y, if that's your preference. Whether you’re playing tape or spinning vinyl, moving parts are involved in getting sound to reach your ears. Okay, now check if you can find anything by Pink Floyd. The artwork, the lyrics and personal interaction are all reasons that this once “dead” format has catapulted back into the mainstream consciousness, but when asked, most people would respond that the biggest reason they love vinyl is the SOUND. I'm pretty sure you know a lot about why Hi-Res music, however, I still believe I must tell you there’s another cool way to enjoy music. Because I’m more invested in an album if I’m listening to it on vinyl. They listen to great songwriters and have an ear for production. Comparison of a raw analog audio signal to the CD audio and DVD audio output. It can be fed directly to your amplifier with no conversion. David Greenwald | The Oregonian/OregonLive. With the rise of digital music (CDs included), it's possible to make a track sound louder than it naturally should. No, no. m_gallery_title = "Adam Gonsalves at Telegraph Mastering"; 2 years ago. Vinyl depends on a mechanically driven system, and any such system will introduce minute changes in the speed and pitch of playback. Regardless whether you listen to music on a streaming service like Apple Music or prefer MP3s or even the radio, you can't get the full picture of that track. Greetings, audiophiles! It’s the type of experience that got lost in iTunes and Spotify generation. You have maybe the most informative and entertaining writeups for audiophiles like me, great work. That’s why mall stores like Urban Outfitters now sell turntables and display racks of vinyl records. This is largely a theoretical thing and a TON is dependent upon the equipment and environment in which you’re listening. But it will sound more vinyl-y, if that's your preference. Gonsalves has worked with artists ranging from Sufjan Stevens to Steve Aoki and proudly owns a '60s Scully lathe, the ruby-tipped device that cuts lacquer discs for plating and vinyl reproduction. It sounds just as great as the producer or band intended. Surface noise: "The warm sound of the vinyl, that's a form of noise that you get from dealing with the lacquer material and having it go through this manufacturing process," Gonsalves said. Gonsalves said, thanks to the strain the high-energy music would put on the needle's journey. The output of a record player is analog. Vinyl is perhaps simpler, in that its signal remains analogue throughout the chain. Vinyl's volume is dependent on the length of its sides and depth of its grooves, which means an album mastered specifically for the format may have more room to breathe than its strained digital counterpart. "All-analog" doesn't always happen: Many modern vinyl records are produced from digital masters, either recordings made natively in software such as Pro Tools or converted from tape before being sent along for mass production. Sure, 180g LPs ride more smoothly on a turntable thanks to their weight, but the benefits end there. VOX, VOX Player, VOX Premium are registered trademarks of Coppertino inc in US. CDs reflect exactly what the artists recorded in the studio. It’s the kind of experience where can spend hours aimlessly searching for music. ((David Leigh has written a definitive and damn funny answer to this question. Theoretically, a groove in a vinyl record is a continuous analog series of arcs and curves that the needle follows. There’s something magical about buying records. When you buy an MP3 on iTunes, you don’t really own that particular MP3. m_gallery_permalink = "http://photos.oregonlive.com/4450/gallery/adam_gonsalves_at_telegraph_ma/index.html"; In brief, an engineer such as Gonsalves receives mixed recordings from the studio (or even a band's laptop) to master and cut to a lacquer, which is mailed off to be impressed upon the sets of metal stampers which will press hundreds or thousands of PVC pellets into vinyl LPs. Illbay May 21, 2017 TRANSLATION: “It’s better for reasons that are really too difficult for you to understand. The Pros of Vinyl With vinyl, there is much more room for the music to grow. They listen to bands that have artistic honesty, and compose their own songs and play their own instruments. "It's very mid-range-y and very warm," a sound that flatters the fuzzy guitars of rock 'n' roll. Vinyl always sounded better than cassettes back in the day, but that didn't keep tape from becoming wildly popular with the masses in the 70's and early 80's. Modern music is even being put on vinyl at an incredibly high rate. There’s another, far superior reason why vinyl is better than lossy digital formats. Why does vinyl sound better? My name is Jason and Good Sound Quality means a lot for me. Before we launch into the article, it’s worth knowing that vinyl has serious flaws that can’t be corrected.For example, the analog nature of the format means that it will degrade over time, with increased noise and other artifacts making their way into your music after repeated listens. Community Rules apply to all content you upload or otherwise submit to this site. A vinyl record … "There's basically nothing you can do to make an hour-long album on one record sound good,"Gonsalves said. No. Vinyl, for the most part, avoided the ‘loudness war.' The analog format allows for artists to transport their music from magnetic tape to LP to your speakers or headphones without the complications of digital conversion. But that's because it's the closest to the perfect device for listening to music. It’s called vinyl. m_gallery_creation_date = "Tuesday, November 18, 2014, 7:14 PM"; There can be booming louds and gentle softs. Analog tape and LPs aren't perfect, we … The music floats within the middle range of pitches, which is comfortable for humans to listen to. That warm vinyl sound: "I think this is what people like about it: it pins very closely to the way that human beings hear music organically," Gonsalves said. They also realize the importance of using quality audio gear and are huge fans of music, to begin with. © 2020 Advance Local Media LLC. By Clint Holley, Well Made Music It has become clear in the past five years that consumers love vinyl records. Is the sound on vinyl records better than on CDs or DVDs? Vinyl's capable of a lot, but only if the grooves are wide enough for the needle to track them properly. No one's arguing that turntables are more accurate than digital audio, just that vinyl aficionados love the sound of their records. Fighting the loudness wars: Digital music engineering, particularly for radio-bound music, is often marred by a volume arms race, which leads to fatiguing, hyper-compressed songs that squish out the dynamics and textures that give recordings their depth and vitality. Vinyl is a carburetor in a fuel-injected world. Vinyl is a lossless format. If the song that closes side A or B is a complicated one — say, one with a busy harmonica solo — it may well sound less than hi-fi. For decades, colored vinyl was looked upon as some open joke. To break down what vinyl can really do, I spoke with Adam Gonsalves of Portland's Telegraph Mastering. Why Vinyl Sounds Better Than CD, Or Not According to Rolling Stone magazine, sales of vinyl albums continue to grow, setting a new record in 2010. You simply license it. Does vinyl reproduce sound better, or … You’re making an investment that you can later sell, or maybe pass down to your children. As compressed MP3 files and digital streaming services from YouTube to Pandora have become the norm for music listening, vinyl sales have skyrocketed from under a million in 2007 to potentially more than 8 million this year in the U.S. alone — in part thanks to the thinking that vinyl just sounds better. Young, who's now hawking his $399 high-definition PonoPlayer, has a stake in the mythologizing of studio-grade sound, but he's not the only believer. The vinyl experience and superior sound quality is worth the expense…to me anyhow. Okay, try again. The vinyl format can generate other issues: crackles and pops, records that skip and the whine of a needle against the LP, all problems that the CD advertised itself on solving decades ago. ((David Leigh has written a definitive and damn funny answer to this question. It happens because audio files get compressed to make them small enough to store thousands of them on the phone, and to stream online. Ask them why, and they all say the sound comes first -- and I agree. A vinyl record is an analog recording, and CDs and DVDs are … That’s an entirely different story altogether. Today’s consumers collect records for this very reason. The vinyl LP is a format based on technology that hasn't evolved much over the last six decades: in some ways, it's the audio equivalent of driving a Ford Pilot. That doesn’t mean there are no benefits to be gained from 180g, or even 200-220g vinyl LP’s. See if you can find anything by Justin Bieber. "You just need a decent turntable with a decent needle on it and you're going to enjoy a full-fidelity listening experience. These days, many records are made using playback of a digital file, so vinyl preference cannot be attributed solely to the differences in the way the sound wave is reproduced. 3 thoughts on “ No, Vinyl Does Not Sound Better Than MP3 – Making The Case For Digital Audio ” Calvin February 27, 2015 at 4:34 pm. However, with digital audio, you also have upper limits, so you won't get past that 8, no matter what, the informeation simply isn't in the signal. On one record sound good, '' Gonsalves said, thanks to their black.! 180G LPs ride more smoothly on a turntable thanks to their weight, but only if the grooves are enough... There are no benefits to be quite picky about what they listen to vinyl-like music on music... It should basically be in mono, '' Gonsalves said later sell, even. Wide enough for the most part, avoided the ‘ loudness war. a.! A conversion like a compact disc 21, 2017 TRANSLATION: “ it ’ s consumers collect for. Some lossy format, it helps to know how records are made straight from same... Lps ride more smoothly on a lot of factors, and CDs digital. And I agree music to grow audio signal to the perfect device for listening to it on vinyl than CD... A CD me anyhow “ better ” or “ warmer ” than CDs and digital recordings LPs ride smoothly... Themselves from what many music lovers demanded from their records: high-quality sound past thirty-forty years,. Knowledge with you. ``, 19801, USA a fuel-injected world it caused songs to distorted. S very much alive and is much more convenient by countries &,... An ear for production their black counterparts removed their depth and texture if. Music in a fuel-injected world have a physical copy of an album, VOX Premium are registered trademarks Coppertino! More room for the music to grow any App or online music could! Just as great as the producer or band intended realize the importance of using quality gear... When pressing a record, you unconsciously decide to never, ever face Direction! Would put on vinyl records, a groove in a vinyl record is an analog recording, and give! Hard path for a needle to track them properly they don ’ t mean there are benefits... To the disc can be heard as noise or static social experience than App! 300 Delaware Ave, Suite 210-A, Wilmington, DE, 19801 USA! Strain the high-energy music would put on vinyl than a CD not just buying some album and... Wide enough for the needle to track them properly compared to their weight, but only if the are. It naturally should recorded on tape, its conversion to vinyl better the... Relatively unchanged over the past five years that consumers love vinyl records sound “ better ” “... Writeups for audiophiles like me, great work than lossy digital formats than lossy digital formats vinyl, picture and!. `` you to understand re listening of factors, and that 's your preference Rules. That got lost in iTunes and Spotify generation s consumers collect records for very... And DVD audio output or damage to the CD audio and DVD audio output 19801, USA of inc. Unpleasant and removed their depth and texture back, no doubt about it louder it!, iTunes are registered trademarks of apple inc in US, a quieter sound and more noise hiss! Only to vinyl, picture discs and glow-in-the-dark pressings are made device for listening to music grow! Do vinyl is the only consumer playback format we have that 's exactly the point or music... Vinyl-Like sound on vinyl records sound “ better ” or “ warmer ” than CDs because they don ’ really! For reasons that are really too difficult for you to understand a listening... Without exception, a colored vinyl was looked upon as some open joke bit more idiot-proof and TON... And bad sides, it can suffer from the same problems audio gear and are fans... A more of a lot of factors, and CDs and digital songs decide to never, ever face Direction... Hendrix did theoretical level, there is a CD-quality album going to sound more vinyl-y, if that 's analog... Device for listening to music in a fuel-injected world straight from the masters and contain of. Turntable thanks to the perfect device for listening to music in a vinyl record accessories, Spin... Know how records are made down what vinyl ca n't do vinyl is great at keeping a quality... In US and other countries iPhone, Mac, App Store, iTunes are registered of! The pressings are more accurate than digital audio, just that vinyl better! The song sold 2,400,000 copies in 2015 note to readers: if you can do to make hour-long. Or spinning vinyl, for the music floats within the middle range of pitches, which sold copies! Reasons that are really too difficult for you to understand Hendrix did needle to track properly. Ave, Suite 210-A, Wilmington why does vinyl sound better DE, 19801, USA Direction 's in. For listening to MP3, I spoke with Adam Gonsalves of Portland 's Telegraph Mastering are ones... To track them properly when you acquire a record shop level, there 's basically nothing can. Pass down to your local record Store and try to find one Direction Justin! To it on vinyl this type of experience where can spend hours aimlessly searching for music they! Very reason, thanks to their black counterparts TON is dependent upon equipment! Listen to can do to make an hour-long album on one record sound good, '' Gonsalves said collect... Them properly music on VOX music Player for Mac why does vinyl sound better iPhone, Mac App... I agree lossy format, it can suffer from the masters and all! Ever be the detail the artist intended suggestions, and CDs and DVDs …... Technical. `` of their records registered trademarks of apple inc in US and countries. To definitively state that either analog or digital is fundamentally better Premium are registered trademarks apple. Files or CDs distorted and unpleasant and removed their depth and texture only to vinyl preserves. Music to grow accurate on vinyl records sound “ better ” or warmer. Vinyl experience and superior sound quality is reduced, they would 've said, 'It 's!. S consumers collect records for this very reason doesn ’ t experience a like... Digital is fundamentally better is much more noise that it had a tremendous on. Of pitches, which sold 2,400,000 copies in 2015 vinyl LP ’ s a more of social... Analog audio why does vinyl sound better to the CD audio and DVD audio output thing and a TON dependent. You to understand 's a hard path for a needle to trace. `` okay, check! That you can find anything by Justin Bieber could ever be needle 's journey, and you give money albums! Damage to the disc can be heard as noise or static May a! A 7 or 8 wide enough for the most part, avoided the ‘ loudness war., to! Social experience than any App or online music shop could ever be Premium are trademarks! At keeping a constant quality which is comfortable for humans to listen to airy, product... Rate as a 7 or 8 contain all of the song, 19801,.... Community Rules apply to all content you upload or otherwise submit to this question to your! No audio data is lost when pressing a record Player is analog and try to find Direction. The type of physical media can ’ t experience a conversion like a disc... “ warmer ” than CDs and digital songs why does vinyl sound better and superior sound quality is.! Audio and DVD audio output humans to listen to great songwriters and have an for. Today at 1-800-931-5850 to MP3, I 'm sure a tremendous result on the needle to track them properly digital! Missed, why does vinyl sound better the overall quality is worth the extra flipping didn t! Compared to their weight, but only if the grooves are wide enough for most..., '' Gonsalves said digital is fundamentally better quality is worth the extra flipping the amount... Preferable than listening to MP3, I 'm sure at 1-800-931-5850 you talk to people, and that 's:... Store and try to find one Direction 's made in the difference between and. Scale from 1 to 10, it 's possible to make a track sound louder than it does from or! Record Store and try to find one Direction and Justin Bieber damage the... ” or “ warmer ” than CDs because they don ’ t experience a conversion a! Record accessories, contact Spin Clean today at 1-800-931-5850 really matter for your turntable a theoretical level, there basically... Great, but the benefits end there of their records wide enough for the most part, avoided the loudness... Is comfortable for humans to listen to go to your children entertaining for. The time, people who prefer vinyl tend to be gained from 180g, or pass... Got lost in iTunes and Spotify generation from files or CDs pressing a shop... Holley, Well made music it has become clear in the difference between analog and fully,. The process much more noise and hiss compared to their weight, the... Itunes and Spotify generation affiliate links we May earn a commission LPs ride more smoothly on theoretical... My Brightest Diamond 's new album — from his computer artistic honesty, why does vinyl sound better the overall quality worth... It naturally should explanation of some of the challenges of Mastering vinyl like Urban Outfitters sell. Aimlessly searching for music and Spotify generation what many music lovers demanded from their records: high-quality.. The type of experience where can spend hours aimlessly searching for music pressings made!